Published
3PL or your own warehouse? How Australian businesses decide
Outsourcing to a 3PL or running your own warehouse: costs, control and risks compared, with the questions that usually decide it.
Sooner or later, every business that sells physical products has to decide who runs its warehouse. You can lease a site, buy racking and hire a team, or you can hand the work to a 3PL. Neither is always cheaper. It depends on your volume, your products and how much control you want.
The two options side by side
| Using a 3PL | Your own warehouse | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Low: setup and onboarding fees at most. | High: lease, bond, fit-out, racking, forklifts and equipment. |
| Ongoing cost | Pay per pallet, order and job. Rises and falls with volume. | Mostly fixed: rent, wages, insurance and utilities, busy or not. |
| Commitment | Contract terms, often months rather than years. | Commercial leases in Australia commonly run for several years. |
| Peak season | The 3PL absorbs the extra orders with its own staff and space. | You hire casuals and find space yourself. |
| Control | Through the 3PL's rules, cut-off times and systems. | Full control over processes, packaging and priorities. |
| Staff | The 3PL hires, trains and manages them. | You hire, train, roster and manage, including WHS obligations. |
| Locations | Use 3PLs in more than one city without opening sites. | Each new location is a new lease and team. |
When a 3PL usually wins
- You are growing quickly and cannot predict how much space you will need next year.
- Your sales are seasonal, with a big peak around Black Friday and Christmas.
- You want stock in Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane for faster delivery.
- Your team should be spending time on products and sales, not rosters and forklifts.
- You are an overseas brand testing the Australian market.
When your own warehouse usually wins
- Your volume is high and steady, so you can keep a warehouse and team busy all year.
- Your products need special handling, such as bulky items, dangerous goods or custom assembly.
- The packing experience is part of your brand and you want it done your way.
- You also sell wholesale or run a showroom from the same site.
The hidden costs on both sides
With a 3PL, watch for minimum monthly charges, extra fees for work outside the standard rate card, and the cost of moving out. Our guide to 3PL pricing lists the fees to ask about. With your own warehouse, people underestimate staff turnover, training time, insurance, equipment maintenance, and the cost of stock errors when there is no proper system.
A simple way to decide
- Take your last 12 months of orders and pallets.
- Ask two or three 3PLs to quote on those numbers, including your peak month.
- Cost your own warehouse for the same year: rent, outgoings, wages including super, equipment, insurance and software.
- Compare the totals, then weigh control, risk and how much of your own time each option takes.
Running your own warehouse? Use a WMS
If you keep the warehouse in-house, the biggest step up from spreadsheets is a warehouse management system. It records where every item is, checks picks by barcode and keeps stock accurate without weekly full counts. EZwarehouse works for your own warehouse as well as for 3PLs, with real-time inventory tracking and scanning on a phone or handheld scanner.
Frequently asked questions
Is a 3PL cheaper than running my own warehouse?
At low or uneven volume, usually yes, because you only pay for what you use. At high, steady volume, your own warehouse can cost less per order, provided you keep it busy and run it well.
Can I use a 3PL and my own warehouse together?
Yes. Many businesses keep their main warehouse and use a 3PL in another state for faster delivery, or send overflow stock to a 3PL during peak season.
How long does it take to move to a 3PL?
It depends on the 3PL and your range, but it usually means setting up your products, connecting your store, and sending stock in, then running both side by side for a short period.